Nanette McGuinness 00:00
We recorded the following interview with multi-talented librettist, musicologist, and musician Kendra Preston Leonard in August 2025. Sadly, she passed away suddenly and much too young on August 19, 2026. We are so grateful to have had the opportunity to speak to her, and we dedicate the following episodes with her to her memory. [INTRO MUSIC] Welcome to For Good Measure, an interview series celebrating diverse composers and other creative artists. I'm Nanette McGuinness, Artistic Executive Director of Ensemble for These Times. In this week's episode, we continue our conversation with Kendra Preston Leonard. [INTRO MUSIC ENDS]
Nanette McGuinness 00:53
Looking at other operas, we've spoken about the Medusa one....
Kendra Preston Leonard 00:59
Yes.
Nanette McGuinness 00:59
...but you've also got a new opera, Montevergine, right?
Kendra Preston Leonard 01:03
Montevergine. Si.
Nanette McGuinness 01:05
Ah, Monte... Montevergine. Okay, Montevergine. And tell us about that.
Kendra Preston Leonard 01:10
So composer Stephen Sérpa came to me, and he'd gotten a request from Opéra Queens, they're based in Canada and in the United States. They wanted to put on a double bill where they would do a cross-dressed Suor Angelica, and then they wanted a new opera that interrogated the intersections of faith and queerness.
Nanette McGuinness 01:37
Wow!
Kendra Preston Leonard 01:38
And yeah, so I was very very excited about this.
Nanette McGuinness 01:42
Yes.
Kendra Preston Leonard 01:42
And we kicked around a whole bunch of different ideas, and then Stephen read this legend, and it's a, it's a Neapolitan legend that says that... I'll back up a little bit.
Nanette McGuinness 01:56
[laughs]
Kendra Preston Leonard 01:56
There's a traditional pilgrimage...
Kendra Preston Leonard 01:58
...to Montevergine for February, in February...
Kendra Preston Leonard 01:59
uhuh
Nanette McGuinness 02:02
Okay.
Kendra Preston Leonard 02:02
...and pilgrims would travel from all over what is now Italy to Montevergine to, to make this pilgrimage, where they would pray at the shrine of one of The Black Madonnas, and your listeners, I'm sure, can look up Black Madonnas, but the idea is that it is a painting of the Virgin Mary and the Infant Jesus done in such a way that the skin tone, particularly of Mary, is, is very dark. So Montevirgine has one of these black moons. Montevergine is also built on the site of an ancient Temple Cybele, who had among her devotees priests who were Eunuchs, and functioned in a third gender kind of way. Naples also has a community of a third gender called the femminielli. The femminielli are boys who identify very young as girls, so they are, they're assigned male at birth, but they are trans.
Nanette McGuinness 03:07
mmhmm
Kendra Preston Leonard 03:07
And they are handed over at a young age from their families to other women to raise as femminielli. They were not typically Eunuchs, but... they also fill in this, this space that is sort of almost a little parallel Cybele's acolytes.
Nanette McGuinness 03:15
mmhmm
Kendra Preston Leonard 03:17
So, so the, the legend that Stephen found was a pair of gay lovers made the pilgrimage to Montevergine, and they were caught together by the priests and the community, and as it was cold, and no one wanted to spend firewood on them, they were tied up outside naked to either freeze to death or for the wolves, which were apparently plentiful, to come eat them.
Nanette McGuinness 03:54
Wow.
Kendra Preston Leonard 03:55
But The Black Madonna appeared and forgave them.
Nanette McGuinness 04:01
Hmm... okay.
Kendra Preston Leonard 04:03
So this could not have been a better setting and story for something that interrogates the intersections of queerness and faith.
Nanette McGuinness 04:10
Yeah.
Kendra Preston Leonard 04:10
And so again, I threw myself into research for it. It was absolutely amazing. Listened to interviews with some of Naples' femminielli. Listened to the kind of music that was used in the procession for the pilgrimage. Did a whole bunch of reading, and so Stephen and I put together this, this work. And Stephen is still working on the score, but, but our story is that there are two young men who are planning on going on pilgrimage together, they're lovers. As a gesture of good luck, their parents hire one of the femminielli to escort them to the city gates because being touched by or sung to or dancing with a femminiello was considered good luck. So the femminiello as they guide them to the gates, warns the lovers, "Don't be obvious; you could get in trouble." And the young man promised to be very careful. And despite being careful, however, they are caught. And in the midst of this, the priest who catches them, who is in charge of things at Montevergine, used to be their parish priest, he is struggling with his own gayness...
Nanette McGuinness 05:24
Oh interesting.
Kendra Preston Leonard 05:25
...and he's having a really hard time trying to grapple with the feelings that he has and the ideas about his identity, with his vocation and things like that. And so, when the young men are to be executed, it's not just The Black Madonna who shows up, but also Cybele to bless them and to tell the gathered folk that love is never a sin.
Nanette McGuinness 05:56
mmhmm
Kendra Preston Leonard 05:57
And then we have a short epilog that takes place, you know, 700 years later, where pilgrims are going to Montevergine in the present day, which they still do, and there's a huge queer pilgrimage there. It is absolutely amazing. It's, it's like the biggest Pride march festival of, of Italy. It's, it's enormous.
Nanette McGuinness 06:21
I had no idea.
Kendra Preston Leonard 06:21
So we have this, we have this scene where all of the characters are back, but they are in modern dress and they are dancing together. And one of them says, "Oh, you guys need to meet my friend, and it's the priest, right, in his new incarnation...
Nanette McGuinness 06:37
Oh!
Kendra Preston Leonard 06:38
...happily dancing, expressing queer joy, Steve and I felt it was really important that it end with something that shows queer joy. So that, that's the story, and that's sort of how it came together. We had a couple of choruses from it sung by the Inversion Ensemble in Austin, Texas, in March, and one of the really special things about that, not just including the Inversion Ensemble is phenomenal, but Stephen was also able to get a hold of a special drum called the Tammorra, which was played by the femminielli. So we found someone who knew how to play the drum, and we had the authentic drum there that would have been used, and it was just a fabulous performance. Which is great.
Nanette McGuinness 07:22
It sounds great, and it also sounds very much like a story for these times.
Kendra Preston Leonard 07:27
It does absolutely. It is absolutely for these times, and we wanted to show. You know, I mean, part of the part of the the... the message I feel like that the queer community, and I'm part of that, wants to get out is that we have always been here.
Nanette McGuinness 07:44
mmhmm
Kendra Preston Leonard 07:44
There has never been a time in human history, you know, where everybody was straight. There just that's never happened, right?
Nanette McGuinness 07:51
Right.
Kendra Preston Leonard 07:52
So, so being, finding this legend, this medieval legend, and being able to incorporate that into a story that is ultimately about joy and love, just felt perfect to Stephen and me, and we, we had a great time working on it.
Nanette McGuinness 08:07
Yeah, I can... I can tell, and I agree...
Kendra Preston Leonard 08:09
Yeah.
Nanette McGuinness 08:09
...very much agree.
Kendra Preston Leonard 08:10
Yeah, and we also spent a lot of time looking at Suor Angelica because it's meant to be on a double bill with Suor Angelica. It'll be able to stand on its own, of course, but... so we spent a lot of time looking at the score, and I spent a lot of time with the libretto and listening to different recordings as well, you know, to try and, you know, the, the moment when Angelica is saved because Mary appears to her, right?
Nanette McGuinness 08:32
Right.
Kendra Preston Leonard 08:33
It's this transcendental moment in music, and it's just stunning. And we wanted to have a similar feeling for Montevergine.
Nanette McGuinness 08:41
Yeah, yeah, it is translucent, actually.
Kendra Preston Leonard 08:44
Yes.
Nanette McGuinness 08:44
The word trans comes up with lots of different endings...
Kendra Preston Leonard 08:48
Yep.
Nanette McGuinness 08:48
...to it, for that moment, transfixing, you know, pick your...
Kendra Preston Leonard 08:51
Yeah.
Nanette McGuinness 08:52
It is magic. So, did you find, or do you find it... if you're working with a historical topic, and that, this is a historical topic with legend and history all thrown together... Do you find it easier, harder, or no different than writing a libretto that is, you know, based on contemporary topics or scenes? You know, the... how does that feel?
Kendra Preston Leonard 09:16
It feels about the same to me. I will go down longer rabbit holes. The older the history is.
Nanette McGuinness 09:23
[laughing] But they're fun rabbit holes, right?
Kendra Preston Leonard 09:27
But they're fun rabbit holes, and I love doing the research. That's one of the things I love about being a librettist and lyricist is that I get to engage in research and I get to engage with history and archeology and social customs and things like that, and that's just always fascinating to me. So I would say it's the same. It's just that I might, you know, find notes to write 10 other pieces on the side, you know, because of what I find doing the research on something that's, that's more historical.
Nanette McGuinness 10:00
Yeah.
Kendra Preston Leonard 10:00
And I have to. I'm thinking about it now, and you know, a lot of my pieces, a lot of the libretti that I've written, are historical to some extent. So there's Marie Curie, there's Montevergine...
Nanette McGuinness 10:12
Yep.
Kendra Preston Leonard 10:13
Protectress is not historical, but I still needed to do historical research for it because attitudes and rights and characters needed to mesh at least a little bit with the traditional characters that I was using.
Nanette McGuinness 10:29
Correct.
Kendra Preston Leonard 10:31
So, Sense of Self, for example, that one. It's very timely. It's very now. It's very topical, but it's also something that came out of some research. The history of Lisa and I are both athletes, and we wanted to write something about women athletes. We actually wrote a couple of pieces about women athletes, and so part of that was doing research as well and looking at how women, professional athletes or elite athletes in particular, who've had to deal with breast cancer...
Nanette McGuinness 11:02
mmm
Kendra Preston Leonard 11:02
...have made the decisions that they did. So I read a lot of articles and interviews with athletes who talked about the kind of treatments they went through and how they decided on their treatments and things like that.
Nanette McGuinness 11:12
It's interesting. So was your sport swimming? Since that's...
Kendra Preston Leonard 11:16
I do swim.
Nanette McGuinness 11:18
[laughs]
Kendra Preston Leonard 11:18
I do swim. I was involved in equestrian sports when I was very young.
Nanette McGuinness 11:23
Ah, of course.
Kendra Preston Leonard 11:23
Horse girl.
Nanette McGuinness 11:24
Yeah.
Kendra Preston Leonard 11:25
And then I was involved in competitive fencing for a long time, both as a competitor and as a coach.
Nanette McGuinness 11:30
Again, you probably do not know this, but my son was a fencer.
Kendra Preston Leonard 11:36
What weapon?
Nanette McGuinness 11:37
Épée.
Kendra Preston Leonard 11:37
I love epic fencing.
Kendra Preston Leonard 11:39
Which was yours?
Kendra Preston Leonard 11:41
So I wanted to fence épée mostly...
Nanette McGuinness 11:45
Yeah.
Kendra Preston Leonard 11:45
...but the area we lived in, most of the time when, when I was fencing was really foil heavy.
Nanette McGuinness 11:50
Foil, mmhmm.
Kendra Preston Leonard 11:50
They didn't have a lot of épéeists and not very many épée coaches. So mostly I fenced foil. I did a little bit of sabre.]
Nanette McGuinness 11:53
mmhmm
Kendra Preston Leonard 11:55
I did some épée when I could, but we'd go to tournaments and there'd be like three people who showed up for épée.
Nanette McGuinness 12:03
[laughs]
Kendra Preston Leonard 12:03
And I was like, "Come on!" You know... My husband... that's how my husband and I met. We met at fencing. He's a sabre fencer, or was a sabre fencer. So yeah, mostly foil for me. And we retired. We retired about 10 years ago, but we had competed for a long time, and then we coached...
Nanette McGuinness 12:23
Nice!
Kendra Preston Leonard 12:24
...and I loved it. And I did serve as an épée coach at the fencing club that we were part of. But you know, it's like when you have two kids who want to fence épée, and... it's sort of...
Nanette McGuinness 12:37
It's not going to work.
Kendra Preston Leonard 12:38
It was hard to do at the time, and I think things have changed in that region, but...
Nanette McGuinness 12:43
Where was that region, I'm sorry?
Kendra Preston Leonard 12:45
It was in Ohio. We lived in Cincinnati, Ohio, so we were competing Ohio, Indiana, Illinois, mostly. Sometimes Michigan..., sometimes Kentucky. It
Kendra Preston Leonard 12:53
...sometimes Kentucky, that area.
Nanette McGuinness 12:54
Yeah.
Nanette McGuinness 12:54
It was luckier out here. We had, I think, four or five clubs, and so there was...
Nanette McGuinness 13:01
That's nice.
Nanette McGuinness 13:01
...you know, and any kid who started fencing over the age of about six or seven was usually pushed more towards épée. But he was a good fencer. He got as far as the Junior Olympics.
Kendra Preston Leonard 13:11
That's great. Does he still fence?
Nanette McGuinness 13:12
...and through college. No. After he left college, I think he and his wife moved more towards. I shouldn't say "I think" I know they moved more towards climbing, and they now do mountain rescue. They're active.
Kendra Preston Leonard 13:24
Oh, that's fabulous!
Nanette McGuinness 13:25
Yeah, so they do that instead, and they volunteer...
Kendra Preston Leonard 13:27
That's great.
Nanette McGuinness 13:28
...they're really active with that. You know, I was sad when he left fencing because I thought here is a sport that you can do when you're 50 or 55.
Kendra Preston Leonard 13:35
Yes.
Nanette McGuinness 13:35
But you know, you have to follow what you...
Kendra Preston Leonard 13:39
Yeah.
Nanette McGuinness 13:39
...what your heart says, and they're very active with that instead.
Kendra Preston Leonard 13:42
That's really cool.
Nanette McGuinness 13:43
...and probably more fit than they would be if they were doing fencing, because you know, I've seen a lot of unfit fencers, even though it shouldn't be so.
Kendra Preston Leonard 13:51
Because it's not an aerobic sport. It's anaerobic. Yeah, yeah. Because you're not always moving.
Nanette McGuinness 13:58
You have those bursts.
Kendra Preston Leonard 13:58
It's move stop. Move stop.
Nanette McGuinness 13:59
Yeah.
Kendra Preston Leonard 14:00
Move stop. Move, move, move stop.
Nanette McGuinness 14:02
Right. [laughs]
Kendra Preston Leonard 14:04
So if you want to be fit in terms of anaerobic exercise, you get that through footwork and stuff, but it still is not the same as running or you know, other sports... skiing, I guess. Yeah.
Nanette McGuinness 14:16
Yeah, that's so interesting. You and I have so many points in common. I am amazed.
Kendra Preston Leonard 14:22
I know, I'm, and I'm sad that we did not know this earlier, but I'm glad that we know it now.
Nanette McGuinness 14:26
Exactly, me too. Me too.
Nanette McGuinness 14:28
[OUTRO MUSIC] Thank you for listening to For Good Measure, and a special thank you to our guest Jennifer Higdon for joining us today. If you enjoyed this episode, please subscribe to our podcast by clicking on the subscribe button and support us by sharing it with your friends, posting about it on social media and leaving us a rating and a review. To learn more about E4TT, our concert season online and in the Bay Area, or to make a tax-deductible donation, please visit us at www.E4TT.org. This podcast is made possible by grants from the California Arts Council, the San Francisco Arts Commission, Grants for the Arts, and generous donors like you. For Good Measure is produced by Nanette McGuinness and Ensemble for These Times, and design by Brennan Stokes, with special thanks to Co-producer and Audio Engineer Stephanie M. Neumann. Remember to keep supporting equity in the arts and tune in next week "for good measure." [OUTRO MUSIC ENDS]